10 excuses Dutch people make for blackface

The Dutch can't hide how racist the "tradition" of the blackface character, Zwarte Piet, is. Here we parody their rationalizations.

Image: Gerald Stolk via Flickr CC License.

It is that time of the year again when Sinterklaas (English: Saint Nicholas) and his little black slaves give candy to children in the Netherlands. As you’re aware, “Zwarte Pieten” (Black Petes) is how the helpers of Saint Nicholas are known. The Sinterklaas character is an old white man resembling Father Christmas. So far, so good. The Zwartepieten, by contrast, come complete with blackface. The blackface is complemented with golliwog-style wigs, pronounced red lips, and a gold earring in one ear. Pieten speak with exaggerated accents. That said, the Dutch can’t hide how racist this “tradition” is anymore. Everyone from the New York TimesBBC to CNN have covered it. We’ve had a few spats on Twitter, Facebook and on Africa is a Country’s social media some people — mostly Dutch, it seems — defend this “tradition” and insist that blackface is just clean fun. Or that the kids like it, so it can’t be bad. Anyway, we compiled a list of the 10 excuses most Dutch people make for this racism. They’re written the way people make these arguments:

1.  Slavery was such a long time ago; slavery has nothing to do with Zwarte Piet. It’s just those who like to be victims, who still complain about slavery. The Dutch only had a small percentage of slaves either way. Rather let’s just talk about the glorious V.O.C (the Dutch East India Company) period and how the Dutch pioneered the trade in goods.

2. The Dutch don’t even see color; everybody is equal here and blacks and whites are totally treated equally. Why else would they want to live here, right? Discrimination in the labor market? That happens to everyone, even people with blonde hair, you know.

3. All children like Zwarte Piet. You can’t take Zwarte Piet away from the kids. It is all for the kids, the kids will not understand if you ban Zwarte Piet, they love it.

4. My black neighbors’ daughter likes Zwarte Piet; see even black people dress up as Zwarte Piet. Are they racist too? And people on Curacao (an island in the Caribbean colonized by the Dutch and still part of its kingdom) also celebrate Zwarte Piet and they love it. If they do it then there must not be anything wrong with it, right?

5. Zwarte Piet is not Blackface; blackface is only in the United States, here it’s just different. Zwarte Piet came through a chimney and that made him black. There’s plenty of neutral and non-biased research that confirms this. And his afro wig, red lips and golden earrings are just funny. Nothing to do with stereotypes.

6. If Zwarte Piet is racist, then white bread is too; everything is reverse racism. You talk about the ‘Dutch being racist’? That’s racist! You want to take away Zwarte Piet from us? That’s racist! You need to respect the Dutch culture or go home. That’s not racist.

7. Opponents and critics of Zwarte Piet are extremist; opponents must at all times refrain from trying to say anything about the national blackface hero in relation to racism. If you speak up in the public domain on Dutch institutional racism and white hegemony, you are an extremist by default.

8. By opposing Zwarte Piet you are actually creating racism; we never had racism but now that these extremists and other folks kept talking about it, well yes, now you have created a divide that didn’t exist before. Racism is just magic.

9. Americans just criticize Zwarte Piet because they are so PC; it’s only folks in the United States and all the other countries that don’t understand Zwarte Piet. How do they dare criticize Dutch culture?! Let them look at themselves first. They don’t understand our Zwarte Piet and us.

10. It’s never our intention to be racist; if you think Zwarte Piet is racist, which he is not, you must understand that if the intention is not racist it can never be racist. You shouldn’t be using the word racism so lightly either way. Just don’t be offended so easily. We make fun of Dutch people, Chinese people, farmers, Negroes, everyone! That’s just Dutch culture — not racism.

Further Reading